Yahoo Answers is shutting down on 4 May 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Why do we separate digits by 10^3?
I know this seems like a stupid question, but why do we separate digits with commas every 3 digits? Is there some sort of reason for this? is it easier to count over 3 digits, rather than 5 or 10? I realize it's partly because of our naming system (thousand, million, billion, trillion), but 3 seems like a very arbitrary number to me.
100 Quintillion
1 * 10^20
100,000,000,000,000,000,000
1,00000,00000,00000,00000
1 Quadripenten (new number naming system?)
1,0000000000,0000000000
1 Billidecen
I realize you would need new number systems, so I guess
10 = ten
100 = duen
1000 = trien
10000 = quadren
100000 = penten
------------------------
1000000 = sexten
10000000 = septen
100000000 = octen
1000000000 = nonen
10000000000 = decen
I figure if our number system is base ten, why not separate our digits in groups of 10? or maybe 5? something that's easier to simplify exponents with, rather than by 3 (doesn't divide well with 10).
I suppose the choice of 3 digits might be due to human memory; maybe someone decided that groups of 3 digits were the easiest to remember.
Another reason might be that it's faster to say
Example:
1,243,463
one million two hundred fourty three thousand four hundred sixty three
12,43463
twelve millipenten four quadren three trien four duen sixty three
Although the base-10^5 uses less characters, I suppose it should depend more on the amount of syllables. Both of them end up having 17 syllables as well.
Etymology:
http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=thousand
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/thousand
I'm just curious as to what everyone's opinions on this are. I doubt any change would ever happen, just like converting from the US system of weights and measures to the metric system, or from pi to tau.
I realize anywhere from 1 to 10 zeroes in a row might be hard to count, but it's pretty hard to mess up when there's only 1 to 5
1000 = 1,000
10000 = 10,000
1,00000 = 100,000
10,00000 = 1,000,000
100,00000 = 10,000,000
etc.
It's also a lot easier to see the difference when you have numbers other than just zero.
I'm not asking why we use commas, I'm asking why we specifically group 3 at a time (or apparently 2 in asian countries?). If it's because of our naming system for numbers, then why did we develop our naming system based on 10^3?
5 Answers
- ?Lv 410 years agoFavourite answer
in the west (most of Europe and America's) one reason is for ease of reading.
another is the most common western language of math groups numbers in three digit sequences:
that is -> ones, tens, hundreds
with each new group of place values having a new additional name
thousands, millions, billions, etc.
so: ones, tens, hundreds, then one thousands, ten thousands, hundred thousands, then on millions, ten millions, hundred millions, etc.
There is no loss of value if the comma's are not used. It really is just for ease of reading.
- ?Lv 45 years ago
I do not agree with the answerer who feel that the credit of all the inventions should go to the Muslims because they seem to have forgotten the history. Before the advent of present day Islam or before Allah (swt) sent the Holy Quran the Arabs were a blot on the name of Humanity. The same people after advent of the present day Islam and taking cue from the Holy Quran started searching for the truth and could make all the above and many more inventions. So I think credit going to Islam is justified. World is controlled by the media now and the media is controlled by the Zionists. This is the reason the world has ignored the Islamic contribution to Science and Literature.
- Tony YoungLv 710 years ago
yeah because it is easier to be recognize because the name of the number are by pairs of zeros exatly by three
for example 1 000. if I write 1000000000000 at first sight you cant tell me which number it is
BUT if I write it like this 1 000 000 000 000 you can easily say it is 1 trillion. you see three pairs make the -llion prefix million,billion.trillion and etc. so you can write close them if you want 1000000000000000 but at leat put comm or point like this 1,000,000,000,000,000
so i gave you two reasons pair of 3 zeroes make -llion and it is easier to be recognized.
- 10 years ago
I think you're asking about culture-specific formatting.
1000000>1,000,000 IN ENGLISH &American style more in western cultures..
in Asia
1000000>10,00,000
1000000000>1,00,00,00,000
because counting numbers are as in west one, ten, thousand ,million and on
but in Asia n India
one ,thousand,lakh(.1M),CRORE(.1b)
Source(s): B
